2013 Cy Young Ballots
| Voter | Lg | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adam Rubin | NL | Kershaw | Fernandez | Harvey | Kimbrel | Wainwright |
| Amanda Comak | NL | Kershaw | Fernandez | Lee | Kimbrel | Zimmermann |
| Andrew Baggarly | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Lee | Bumgarner | Fernandez |
| Anthony Witrado | AL | Scherzer | Iwakuma | Sale | Sanchez | Colon |
| Bernie Miklasz | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Lee | Harvey | Fernandez |
| Bob Klapisch | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Sanchez | Sale | Iwakuma |
| Bob McManaman | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Zimmermann | Harvey | Greinke |
| Chris Iott | AL | Scherzer | Iwakuma | Darvish | Sanchez | Holland |
| Chris Jenkins | NL | Kershaw | Fernandez | Greinke | Harvey | Kimbrel |
| Danny Knobler | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Fernandez | Greinke | Harvey |
| Dennis Manoloff | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Colon | Shields | Sale |
| Dick Scanlon | AL | Scherzer | Uehara | Iwakuma | Moore | Darvish |
| Drew Olson | NL | Kershaw | Kimbrel | Wainwright | Fernandez | Zimmermann |
| Gaku Tashiro | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Iwakuma | Sale | Colon |
| Geoff Baker | AL | Scherzer | Iwakuma | Sale | Darvish | Sanchez |
| Gerry Fraley | AL | Scherzer | Iwakuma | Colon | Sanchez | Darvish |
| Gordon Edes | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Uehara | Iwakuma | Sale |
| Gordon Wittenmyer | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Lee | Greinke | Zimmermann |
| Guy Curtright | NL | Kershaw | Kimbrel | Wainwright | Greinke | Fernandez |
| Hal McCoy | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Zimmermann | Liriano | Greinke |
| J.P. Hoornstra | AL | Sale | Darvish | Scherzer | Hernandez | Sanchez |
| Jack Etkin | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Fernandez | Harvey | Kimbrel |
| Jack Magruder | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Lee | Fernandez | Kimbrel |
| Jeff Passan | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Sale | Iwakuma | Hernandez |
| Jim Caple | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Iwakuma | Sale | Colon |
| Jim Ingraham | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Uehara | Iwakuma | Sanchez |
| Joe Strauss | NL | Kershaw | Kimbrel | Wainwright | Lee | Fernandez |
| John Maffei | NL | Kershaw | Kimbrel | Zimmermann | Wainwright | Greinke |
| John Perrotto | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Lee | Kimbrel | Fernandez |
| John Shea | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Iwakuma | Sale | Colon |
| John Tomase | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Sale | Iwakuma | Sanchez |
| Jorge Ortiz | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Iwakuma | Sanchez | Colon |
| Joseph Smith | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Iwakuma | Sanchez | Sale |
| Ken Fidlin | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Iwakuma | Sanchez | Colon |
| Ken Rosenthal | NL | Kershaw | Fernandez | Wainwright | Kimbrel | Harvey |
| Kevin Cooney | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Greinke | Kimbrel | Liriano |
| Luis Rangel | NL | Kershaw | Fernandez | Harvey | Lee | Wainwright |
| Manny Navarro | NL | Kershaw | Fernandez | Harvey | Greinke | Wainwright |
| Mark Feinsand | AL | Scherzer | Iwakuma | Darvish | Sale | Sanchez |
| Mark Saxon | NL | Kershaw | Fernandez | Harvey | Lee | Kimbrel |
| Mark Schmetzer | NL | Wainwright | Kershaw | Zimmermann | Fernandez | Lee |
| Mark Whicker | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Kimbrel | Fernandez | Harvey |
| Mike Berardino | AL | Sanchez | Scherzer | Hernandez | Sale | Darvish |
| Mike Kerwick | NL | Kershaw | Fernandez | Harvey | Lee | Wainwright |
| Naoko Sato | AL | Scherzer | Colon | Darvish | Iwakuma | Sanchez |
| Patrick Saunders | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Zimmermann | Kimbrel | Greinke |
| Paul Sullivan | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Zimmermann | Kimbrel | Fernandez |
| Paul White | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Sanchez | Iwakuma | Sale |
| Peter Caldera | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Iwakuma | Sale | Sanchez |
| Phil Miller | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Iwakuma | Sanchez | Sale |
| Ray Ratto | NL | Kershaw | Fernandez | Harvey | Kimbrel | Bumgarner |
| Ryan Lawrence | NL | Kershaw | Harvey | Fernandez | Lee | Wainwright |
| Sam Mellinger | AL | Scherzer | Iwakuma | Sale | Sanchez | Darvish |
| Scot Gregor | AL | Scherzer | Colon | Sanchez | Moore | Darvish |
| Shi Davidi | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Iwakuma | Holland | Sale |
| Tim Kurkjian | AL | Scherzer | Sanchez | Iwakuma | Sale | Darvish |
| Tom Gage | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Colon | Sanchez | Holland |
| Travis Sawchik | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Harvey | Lee | Fernandez |
| Will Carroll | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Harvey | Fernandez | Lee |
| Yuzo Hayakawa | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Iwakuma | Colon | Sanchez |